rantsport.com

Tag: Pundits

  • Football pundits: The voices of the game draw plenty of praise and criticism – but is it justified?

    Football pundits: The voices of the game draw plenty of praise and criticism – but is it justified?

    In 2026, fans pay a lot of money to watch football through all the various subscription platforms. 

    However, are they getting their money’s worth in terms of analysis via the pundits provided by the various TV channels and broadcasters? 

    Rant Sport writer Joe Jones talks us through the pundits of today.

    In 2026 I can guarantee every fan of every club in the top-flight division has a pundit they are not overly keen on. 

    Myself? As an Everton fan I cannot stand the dulcet tones of Andy Hinchcliffe, despite being an ex-Everton player I feel Mr Hinchliffe has something against my beautiful Toffees. 

    Agenda

    A lot of my Liverpool-supporting friends have a certain agenda against Martin Tyler from back in the day – more than likely his subdued nonchalant gimmick when Christian Benteke scored an overhead kick against rivals Manchester United and he barely reacted to the goal.

    Whereas when Anthony Martial came onto the pitch and scored, he laid out the proverbial red carpet with his commentary over his goal, spewing the famous line “Welcome to Manchester Anthony Martial”. 

    And as much as I like the duo of Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher, whenever they commentate on their own teams (Manchester United and Liverpool respectively), I feel agitated by every word as the bias just seeps into their analysis. 

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Pundit news: Pat Nevin on Chelsea, Maresca, Man City, Cole Palmer, Man Utd and more

    Cole Palmer and Enzo Maresca Chelsea
    Cole Palmer and Enzo Maresca Chelsea

    Old days

    It feels like I’m watching the old days of the Fanzone on Sky whenever United play Liverpool – with the constant cuts to Neville and Carragher throughout the game, and when one of them goes silent to celebrate whilst the other miserably analyses the goal.

    Fans of all clubs had famous instances with Michael Owen, who used to come out with now famous quotes such as ‘Whichever team scores the most goals usually wins’ and ‘What a shot, that’s completely unstoppable but the keeper has got to do better for me’.

    Other voices in the industry such as Jim White and Simon Jordan in my opinion don’t offer anything substantial other than breed toxic masculinity into the sport. 

    Scathing attack

    Following Jordan’s scathing attack at Eni Aluko recently, who yes initially never covered herself in glory, it led to yet another mass pile on the former Lioness.

    Sticking with TalkSPORT, I believe the infatuation with Jason Cundy is just bizarre, his ‘bit’ where he lists a bunch of players, ex players and celebrity fans of a club after a humiliating loss just isn’t funny in 2026. 

    Perhaps I need to lighten up and have a bit more fun – but it irks me that a former professional is acting like a manchild. 

    Overarching bias is never a good thing in sport, this is why fans of certain teams prefer to not have certain pundits commentate and analyse their games e.g. Everton and Manchester United fans with Carragher, Celtic with Kris Boyd and Manchester City and Liverpool with Neville.

    Football nerd

    When the game is neutral and the standard pundits have no natural bias, this is often a great platform to highlight the ability of the pundit and show why they get paid the big bucks.

    As a self-proclaimed football nerd, I love seeing the breakdown of all the weekend’s action on Monday Night Football – apart from the section covering Everton, as there will undoubtedly be something that is nitpicked from the game or about the club and not explained with wider context.

    READ NEXT: Welcome to Rant Sport, your new home of news, pundit views and betting tips

  • Pundit news: Pat Nevin on Chelsea, Maresca, Man City, Cole Palmer, Man Utd and more

    Pundit news: Pat Nevin on Chelsea, Maresca, Man City, Cole Palmer, Man Utd and more

    By Liberty Nicholson-Hulse

    Pundit Pat Nevin has offered his assessment of the Premier League landscape, touching on everything from Chelsea’s long-term plans to managerial changes in Manchester, and his analysis of the current transfer market.

    Discussing his former club Chelsea, Nevin pointed to the context surrounding their recent rebuild at Stamford Bridge. 

    With significant spending, a youthful squad and structural change behind the scenes, he argued that progress cannot be simply defined by instant results. 

    Too much movement

    In an exclusive interview with BestBettingSites, former Chelsea and Everton winger Nevin said: “A lot of people were saying it seemed ridiculous because there were too many players moving too quickly. It became about trading more than building a group.”

    Rather than focusing purely on league position, Nevin suggested that long-term planning and developing an identity at Chelsea is essential to their success. 

    “One of the real difficulties is that with this amount of churn, footballers can look and feel like mercenaries and somehow you need to get a group of mercenaries to feel like a team working for each other,” he added. 

    “If you’re changing management teams all the time, that’s hard because you’ve not built an ethic.”

    Stability is key

    In an era of short managerial cycles, Nevin’s remarks underline his belief that sustainable success depends on stability, and that “group ethic has to be stronger”.

    While some supporters remain unconvinced by Enzo Maresca’s tenure in the capital, Nevin believes the broader context paints a more encouraging picture.

    Nevin pointed towards the changes that were made to grow and progress, and admitted that Maresca may be a worthy candidate to take over from Pep Guardiola at Man City when the Spaniard decides his time is done in Manchester. 

    “They changed managers far too often. It’s really a struggle to build things there,” said Nevin.

    “He got them Champions League football. They were in the Club World Cup. And obviously they won a European trophy (UEFA Conference League).

    “He was building something. So he probably showed enough.

    “Enzo learned a lot at Chelsea, and I think he did learn. So I wouldn’t be utterly shocked.”

    Cole Palmer rumours

    Nevin also commented on the speculation around players that could be leaving Chelsea in the summer, including Cole Palmer, boiling major moves down to player preference and power. 

    “I don’t think it comes down to whether Chelsea would sell,” he said in the full interview with BestBettingSites.

    “It actually just comes down to one thing. It doesn’t come down to the clubs, it comes down to him.”

    It’s a reminder that footballers hold more agency than ever before, as personal preference and fit can outweigh the financial pressures. 

    Carrick could be key

    On the prospect of a move up north to Manchester United for Palmer, Nevin commented that recent improvements in personnel at the club are more likely to attract players. 

    “When you look at what United are doing just now and how they’re playing, and the possibility that you might actually have stability at Manchester United, that becomes a temptation. With Michael Carrick, it just feels like a different place. It feels totally different,” he said

    “I hope Michael Carrick gets the job long term.

    “Would that be enough to tempt Cole? I wouldn’t be shocked.”

    Enzo on the move to Madrid?

    Nevin was also asked about the future of Enzo Fernández, who continues to be linked with a move to La Liga giants Real Madrid.

    “Does the world end if he leaves? No. There are other players you would be more concerned about losing.”

    In keeping with his pragmatic stance on transfers, Nevin framed the situation as a strategic decision for Chelsea’s hierarchy. 

    He doesn’t believe Fernandez’s potential departure would derail Chelsea’s long-term project.

    “That would be a tough one for Chelsea. But would everything change for them because of that? No, I don’t think so. Does it change their model? No, I don’t think it does. 

    “Personally, I’d quite like him to stay. But like Cole, it will come down to him.

    “If they let him go, do they think they have someone else who can come in and do at least as good a job cheaper, or a better job for the same amount of money or less? If they think that, they will allow it to happen.”

    However, he acknowledged the unique pull of the Spanish giants.

    “But if Real Madrid want him, they usually get what they want. It’s rare to see a player at the right stage of his career turn down Real Madrid,” said Nevin.

    Once again, the theme is consistent: recruitment and financial power still matter, but in the modern game, the player ultimately holds the power.

    READ NEXT: Welcome to Rant Sport, your new home of news, pundit views and betting tips